The Las Vegas Raiders ended their long-term relationship with franchise quarterback Derek Carr following the 2022 season. Carr subsequently inked a four-year deal worth $150 million with the New Orleans Saints. In 2023, his performance was mixed, tallying 3,878 passing yards and 25 touchdowns, yet he failed to lead the team to the playoffs.

Amidst rising expectations, the Saints drafted quarterback Spencer Rattler from South Carolina in the fifth round of the 2024 NFL Draft. Rattler’s impressive preseason outings have sparked a wave of enthusiasm among the fan base, with some advocating for him to replace Carr as the starting quarterback.

The debate got further attention after NFL analyst Brad Gagnon commented on the situation in a recent Bleacher Report article. Gagnon noted, “While it’s crucial not to put too much stock into performances in the latter stages of pre-season games, Rattler’s potential is intriguing enough to warrant more playtime, especially considering Carr’s pivotal make-or-break upcoming season.”

Since Carr’s departure from the Raiders, both he and his former team have faced challenges. His inaugural season in New Orleans showed potential, but was marred by inconsistency, leading to fan disappointment. Although Rattler hasn’t posted significant stats in his two preseason appearances, his command and poise have not gone unnoticed.

Despite the growing support for Rattler, Carr’s position as starter seems secure for now. However, he must elevate his game in 2024 to fend off the rookie’s challenge. Carr holds the Raiders’ records for both passing yards, at 35,222, and touchdowns, with 217. While he may be past his prime, Carr still needs to demonstrate that he remains the best choice for the Saints moving forward, or else the team might consider a change in leadership.

For continual updates, follow Hondo Carpenter on Twitter @HondoCarpenter and on Instagram @HondoSr. Also, share your thoughts by liking our Facebook page by clicking the link provided.